The Multifaceted Suffering of Workers Under Labor Standards Law Violations in South Korea

The Multifaceted Suffering of Workers Under Labor Standards Law Violations in South Korea

Today's workers in South Korea continue to endure significant hardships due to widespread violations of labor standards laws, despite the existence of comprehensive legal protections. These violations manifest in various forms that impact workers' physical health, mental wellbeing, financial stability, and career development. The suffering experienced is often profound and far-reaching, extending beyond the workplace to affect personal relationships and quality of life.

Workplace Bullying and Harassment: A Growing Epidemic

Workplace bullying represents one of the most psychologically damaging forms of labor law violations faced by Korean workers. Since July 2019, when amendments to the Labor Standards Act specifically prohibiting workplace bullying took effect, there has been increased recognition of this problem[6]. The law defines workplace bullying as actions where "an employer or employee takes advantage of their position or relationship at work to cause physical or mental suffering to other employees or deteriorate the working environment beyond the appropriate scope of work"[6]. Despite this legal framework, bullying remains prevalent in many workplaces.

The manifestations of workplace bullying are diverse and often insidious. Common examples documented in Korean workplaces include verbal abuse, public humiliation, exclusion from work-related information, assigning meaningless tasks, excessive surveillance, and forced participation in after-work gatherings[6][13]. In one documented case, a supervisor repeatedly demanded that a junior employee organize drinking gatherings, stating that "30% of performance bonuses should be used to entertain seniors," while threatening negative consequences for non-compliance[13]. These power dynamics create hostile environments that significantly impact victims' psychological wellbeing.

The consequences of workplace bullying can be severe and sometimes fatal. A tragic case involved an employee at a community credit cooperative who had worked there for 27 years before dying. Although no suicide note was found, the bereaved family strongly indicated workplace bullying as a contributing factor. After five months of investigation, the Ministry of Labor confirmed that the deceased had indeed experienced workplace bullying, including degrading language and surveillance-level monitoring[7]. This case highlights the extreme toll that persistent workplace harassment can take on individuals.

For victims of workplace bullying, suffering extends beyond immediate psychological distress to include long-term mental health conditions. The recognition of these psychological injuries under the Industrial Accident Compensation Insurance Act reflects the serious nature of this form of workplace harm[6]. However, victims often face significant challenges in proving their cases and receiving appropriate support and compensation.

Retaliation Against Whistleblowers and Rights Advocates

Workers who report labor law violations or exercise their legal rights frequently face retaliatory actions, creating additional layers of suffering. The Labor Standards Act explicitly prohibits unfavorable treatment of employees who report workplace bullying or other violations, yet such retaliation remains common[6]. This creates a chilling effect that discourages reporting and perpetuates cycles of abuse.

One particularly troubling case involved an employee who reported workplace bullying only to be dismissed shortly afterward under the pretext of unauthorized absence[1]. In another instance, after filing a workplace bullying complaint, an employee was transferred to a location that made commuting by public transportation impossible, forcing them to live in company dormitories[1]. These retaliatory measures not only cause immediate practical difficulties but also isolate victims and compound their psychological distress.

The suffering experienced by those who face retaliation extends beyond the immediate consequences of job loss or relocation. Many victims describe feeling betrayed by systems that should protect them and experience profound isolation when colleagues distance themselves out of fear of association. A legal commentary noted that "many workers suffered physical and mental pain without receiving any relief and left the workplace" before workplace bullying regulations were established[1]. This observation highlights the historical lack of protections that continues to influence workplace cultures today.

Even after workplace bullying regulations were implemented, victims continue to face challenges. As one case demonstrates, "The more time passes, the more anxious the victim worker becomes"[7]. This anxiety stems from the uncertainty of investigative outcomes and fear of continued mistreatment, creating ongoing psychological suffering even after reporting violations.

The Physical and Mental Toll of Excessive Working Hours

Overwork represents another significant source of suffering for Korean workers. Despite legal limitations on working hours, many companies employ various methods to circumvent these restrictions[5][8]. The physical and mental consequences of these violations can be severe and sometimes life-threatening.

A labor inspection of Kakao, a major tech company, revealed systematic violations of working hour regulations. The company required some employees to work beyond the legal limit of 52 hours per week while preventing them from recording overtime hours[8]. Similarly, another company was found to manage working hours within the legal extension work limit while using a separate system to provide compensatory leave for hours exceeding the limit, effectively circumventing the law while requiring extended work[5].

The consequences of excessive working hours are often devastating. In one case, an employee who had worked an average of 12.5 hours daily (250.9 hours over a 30-day period) died, raising suspicions about the connection between excessive workload and the death[5]. This case exemplifies the potentially fatal consequences of working hour violations and the extreme suffering experienced by overworked employees.

The normalization of overwork in certain industries creates environments where employees feel unable to resist demands for extra hours. This leads to chronic fatigue, burnout, and deteriorating physical and mental health. The suffering extends beyond the workplace as excessive working hours leave little time for rest, recreation, or family responsibilities, ultimately diminishing overall quality of life.

Financial Insecurity Through Wage Violations

Non-payment or delayed payment of wages represents a direct form of economic suffering for workers. Various types of wage violations are prevalent in Korean workplaces, including failure to pay overtime premiums, withholding final settlements upon termination, and paying below minimum wage[3][4][9]. These violations create immediate financial hardship and long-term economic insecurity for affected workers.

The Labor Standards Act requires wages to be paid in currency directly to workers, prohibits partial deductions, and mandates payment at least once monthly on a fixed date[9]. However, violations of these provisions remain common across industries. The penalties for wage-related violations can include imprisonment for up to three years or substantial fines, reflecting the serious nature of these infractions[12].

Workers who experience wage violations often face immediate financial crises, including inability to pay for housing, food, and medical care. A particularly vulnerable group includes those who have been dismissed or have resigned due to workplace violations, as they may face delays in receiving their final settlements during already precarious transition periods[3]. The psychological stress of financial insecurity compounds other workplace suffering, creating a cycle of hardship that can be difficult to escape.

The economic suffering caused by wage violations extends beyond immediate financial concerns to include long-term impacts on career development, retirement planning, and overall financial stability. This form of labor law violation thus creates both immediate distress and lasting disadvantage for affected workers.

Psychological Suffering from Emotional Labor

The concept of emotional labor has gained recognition in Korea, particularly for service industry workers who must manage their emotions as part of their job requirements. Since 2018, legal protections for emotional laborers have been implemented, acknowledging the psychological toll this work can take[11]. However, workers in service positions continue to face significant challenges and suffering related to emotional labor demands.

Service workers often face abusive language, unreasonable demands, or harassment from customers while being required by their employers to maintain a pleasant demeanor. Prior to protective regulations, companies frequently failed to defend employees against such treatment, instead forcing them to apologize to abusive customers[11]. This pattern created situations where workers were doubly victimized—first by customer abuse and then by employer indifference or compounded mistreatment.

The psychological suffering resulting from emotional labor includes various mental health conditions that have gained recognition as work-related injuries. The revised Industrial Accident Compensation Insurance Act now recognizes mental illness caused by workplace bullying or customer verbal abuse as legitimate work-related injuries[6]. This legal recognition reflects growing awareness of the legitimate suffering experienced by workers in emotionally demanding positions.

For many workers in service industries, the requirement to suppress genuine emotions while displaying organizationally desired ones creates significant psychological strain. This form of labor, often invisible and uncompensated, takes a substantial toll on mental wellbeing over time. The suffering intensifies when workers lack organizational support or face punishment for failing to maintain emotional performances under abusive conditions.

Vulnerability Through Contract Violations

The absence of proper employment contracts leaves workers particularly vulnerable to exploitation and suffering. Korean labor law requires employers to provide written contracts specifying important working conditions including wages, working hours, holidays, and annual paid leave[9]. Despite this requirement, contract violations remain widespread, creating significant risks for workers.

A public interest organization's analysis found that failure to provide written contracts or properly deliver them to workers accounted for 44% of reported "contract power abuse" cases, making it the most common form of violation[3]. Many employers either fail to create contracts altogether or don't provide copies to workers, leaving employees without documentation of their agreed-upon terms and vulnerable to changing conditions.

Some employers deliberately evade labor laws by misclassifying employees as freelancers or independent contractors[9]. This practice denies workers statutory protections and benefits, exposing them to greater risk of exploitation and mistreatment without legal recourse. The suffering caused by these violations includes increased job insecurity, difficulty asserting workplace rights, and potential loss of benefits and protections that would otherwise be guaranteed by law.

Without clear documentation of employment terms, workers may be subject to undefined expectations, changing conditions, and difficulty proving employer obligations. This uncertainty creates ongoing anxiety and places workers at a significant disadvantage when disputes arise. The psychological burden of navigating employment without clear contractual protection represents a significant form of suffering experienced by many Korean workers.

Barriers to Justice and Enforcement Challenges

Workers experiencing labor law violations face significant obstacles when seeking justice, which compounds their suffering. The process of reporting violations to the Ministry of Employment and Labor can be lengthy and complex, with investigations often taking months to complete[7]. During this time, victims may continue to suffer in hostile work environments or face financial hardship due to lost income.

For workplace bullying cases, the law generally requires internal company procedures as the first step in addressing complaints[7]. This approach can be problematic when the perpetrator is in a position of power or when the company culture tolerates or ignores such behavior. At Naver, for example, an investigation revealed that of 18 reported cases of power abuse, only one was officially recognized as such, and even in that case, the perpetrator received only a minor disciplinary action while the victim ultimately left the company[7]. This pattern creates institutional barriers to justice that prolong suffering for victims.

Even when workers successfully report violations, the remedies may be inadequate. Companies may be given months to address violations before facing penalties[8], during which time workers continue to suffer. Additionally, the fear of retaliation—whether in the form of dismissal, transfer, or more subtle forms of punishment—serves as a powerful deterrent to reporting. This creates a situation where many workers endure ongoing violations in silence rather than risk the consequences of speaking out.

Conclusion

The suffering experienced by workers due to labor standards law violations in South Korea is multifaceted and profound. From the psychological trauma of workplace bullying to the physical toll of excessive working hours, from the financial strain of wage theft to the vulnerability created by contract violations, these infractions cause real harm to workers' lives and wellbeing. The effects extend beyond the workplace to impact personal relationships, mental health, and overall quality of life.

While legal frameworks exist to protect workers' rights, enforcement remains a significant challenge. The power imbalance between employers and employees, combined with procedural hurdles and fear of retaliation, creates an environment where violations can persist despite legal prohibitions. For many workers, the experience of labor law violations is not a singular event but an ongoing condition that shapes their daily lives and long-term prospects.

Addressing this suffering requires strengthened enforcement mechanisms, greater awareness of workers' rights, and cultural shifts within organizations to prioritize compliance and employee wellbeing. Until such changes occur, many Korean workers will continue to endure significant hardships due to labor standards law violations, suffering silently in workplaces that fail to respect their legal rights and human dignity.

Citations:
[1] https://blog.naver.com/lawfluencer/222833665650
[2] https://kilsh.or.kr/2539/
[3] https://yklawfirm.co.kr/yk/views/story/press_view?seq=52049-%EA%B7%BC%EB%A1%9C%EA%B8%B0%EC%A4%80%EB%B2%95%EC%9C%84%EB%B0%98%2C+%EA%B0%80%EB%B3%8D%EA%B2%8C+%EC%83%9D%EA%B0%81%ED%96%88%EB%8B%A4+%EC%A7%95%EC%97%AD%C2%B7%EB%B2%8C%EA%B8%88%ED%98%95+%EB%93%B1+%EC%B2%98%EB%B2%8C+%EB%B0%9B%EB%8A%94%EB%8B%A4
[4] https://www.daeryunlaw-labor.com/field_new/2175
[5] https://www.moel.go.kr/news/enews/report/enewsView.do?news_seq=15618
[6] https://www.kimchang.com/ko/insights/detail.kc?sch_section=4&idx=19107
[7] https://www.jejusori.net/news/articleView.html?idxno=335362
[8] https://www.hani.co.kr/arti/society/society_general/997505.html
[9] https://www.daeryunlaw-labor.com/lawInfo_new/4033
[10] https://blog.naver.com/ejstd007/223361793589
[11] https://blog.naver.com/snpo2013/222380972970?viewType=pc
[12] https://sc.scourt.go.kr/sc/krsc/criterion/criterion_36/labor_standard_01.jsp
[13] http://m.dailypharm.com/newsView.html?ID=254754
[14] https://blog.naver.com/lawand01/223703923797
[15] https://www.law.go.kr/LSW/LsiJoLinkP.do?lsNm=%EA%B7%BC%EB%A1%9C%EA%B8%B0%EC%A4%80%EB%B2%95
[16] https://www.worklaw.co.kr/main2022/view/view.asp?bi_pidx=37233
[17] https://www.easylaw.go.kr/CSP/OnhunqueansInfoRetrieve.laf?onhunqnaAstSeq=82&onhunqueSeq=5876
[18] https://www.moel.go.kr/local/mokpo/common/downloadFile.do;jsessionid=lXnJpiO3WJ044wb199D6HSHXREAt90qMk3xVgg9Krj0qClkJJoxkVcSfs7l2EIXn.moel_was_outside_servlet_wwwlocal?file_seq=21171332845&bbs_seq=23275&bbs_id=LOCAL1
[19] https://www.seoullabor.or.kr/portal/cnts/selectContents.do?cntnts_id=A1000091
[20] https://brunch.co.kr/@@52uy/164
[21] https://www.lawtimes.co.kr/LawFirm-NewsLetter/153788
[22] https://www.worklaw.co.kr/main2022/view/view.asp?bi_pidx=36849
[23] https://www.daeryunlaw-comp.com/success/36
[24] https://www.erc.re.kr/webzine/vol35/sub21.jsp
[25] https://www.moel.go.kr/minwon/fastcounsel/fastcounselView.do?inetDcssMngId=202502240325173850900
[26] https://sc.scourt.go.kr/sc/krsc/pdf/F33.Crimes_of_Labor_Standard.pdf
[27] https://blog.naver.com/sysk2475/120116303149?viewType=pc
[28] https://www.law.go.kr/LSW/lsInfoP.do?lsiSeq=122686
[29] https://labor.moel.go.kr/reportCntr/info.do
[30] https://brunch.co.kr/@@1e0Z/605
[31] https://www.hkn24.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=164682
[32] https://www.worklaw.co.kr/main2022/view/view.asp?in_cate=125&in_cate2=0&bi_pidx=37441
[33] https://www.bbc.com/korean/features-64899677
[34] https://shiftee.io/ko/blog/article/newLaborLawChanges
[35] https://korea.kr/common/download.do?fileId=197588422&tblKey=GMN
[36] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UG8xUrj3OlQ